Quick Answer
Quantitative comparisons and evaluation questions ask for the MISSING information: what datum, if known, would settle the argument? The right answer is the question that cuts both ways — its two possible answers strengthen and weaken respectively.
Visual Summary
- Useful = two-sided — one answer strengthens, the other weakens.
- Settle, not expand — the question resolves the gap.
- Scope discipline — must bear on THIS conclusion.
- Irrelevant facts — already-known data never evaluates.
The Two-Sided Test
An evaluation answer is a QUESTION. Apply the variance test: answer it “yes” — does the argument improve? Answer it “no” — does it collapse? A useful question does both; a one-sided question (either answer strengthens, or neither matters) is wrong. Example: “Did the company’s competitors also cut prices?” — yes: the price cut explains nothing (industry-wide), weakens the strategy claim; no: the cut is distinctive, strengthens.
Scope Discipline
The question must bear on the argument’s ACTUAL conclusion, not adjacent topics. A passage concluding “the new policy reduced accidents” needs questions about accident timing, comparability of periods, or reporting rates — not about the policy’s popularity or cost. The strongest wrong answers are interesting questions about the wrong claim.
Missing-Information Framing
Many evaluate questions reduce to: which number, if revealed, would settle it? A percentage claim needs its base; a per-capita claim needs populations; a before-after claim needs measurement consistency. Train the reflex: conclusion → what datum decides it → which answer choice supplies exactly that.
Exam Angle
Practise the variance test in the GMAT mock — evaluation questions fall fast once the two-sided check is reflexive.
FAQ
What makes an evaluation answer correct?
Its yes and no answers must pull the argument in opposite directions.
Can a relevant-but-known fact be the answer?
No — evaluation asks for missing information, not restated premises.
Related reading
- Sufi and Bhakti Movements Compared: Saints, Orders and Spread | Medieval India One-Pager for Exams
- Indian Society Part 9: Migration and Remittances — A Nation on the Move
Exam angle
How exams use this: Society topics surface as statement-sets on welfare, demographics and social movements. Test it under exam conditions →
Quick revision
- Useful = two-sided: — one answer strengthens, the other weakens.
- Settle, not expand: — the question resolves the gap.
- Scope discipline: — must bear on THIS conclusion.
- Irrelevant facts: — already-known data never evaluates.
- Sufi and Bhakti Movements Compared: Saints, Orders and Spread | Medieval India One-Pager for Exams
- Indian Society Part 9: Migration and Remittances — A Nation on the Move
Have a doubt on this topic?








