Quick Answer
Causal arguments are CR’s favourite target: X correlates with Y, therefore X causes Y. The leap ignores reverse causation (Y causes X), common cause (Z causes both), and coincidence. Master the three attacks and causal-flaw questions become free points.
Visual Summary
- Correlation ≠ causation — the core leap.
- Reverse causation — maybe Y drove X.
- Common cause — Z produced both.
- Time order matters — causes precede effects.
The Three Attacks
Reverse causation: “Cities with more police have more crime, so policing increases crime” — or crime rates drive hiring. A weakener shows the effect preceding the claimed cause. Common cause: a third factor produces both (ice-cream sales and drownings both rise in summer; heat causes each). Coincidence: small samples or short windows produce spurious correlations — extend the data and the link vanishes.
Strengthening Causal Claims
The mirror moves strengthen: eliminate the reverse direction (the cause preceded the effect), rule out the common cause (control groups), or show the dose-response pattern (more X tracks more Y). A well-designed study with a control group is the gold-standard strengthener.
Percentage-Base Confusion
A classic causal-flaw disguise: “the percent of accidents caused by speeding rose” does not mean speeding accidents rose — the base (total accidents) may have shrunk. Absolute numbers versus percents of moving bases: always ask which base, and whether it moved.
Exam Angle
Practise causal attack patterns in the GMAT mock — causal flaws recur in weaken and flaw questions alike.
FAQ
What kills a causal claim fastest?
Showing the effect existed before the claimed cause.
What most strengthens one?
A control group where the cause is absent and so is the effect.
Related reading
Exam angle
How exams use this: Every lane here has a timed mock that mirrors its real marking scheme — reading is step one, recall is the exam. Test it under exam conditions →
Quick revision
- Quick Answer: Causal arguments are CR’s favourite target: X correlates with Y, therefore X causes Y.
- The Three Attacks: Reverse causation: “Cities with more police have more crime, so policing increases crime” — or crime rates drive hiring.
- FAQ: What kills a causal claim fastest?
- Exam angle: How exams use this: Every lane here has a timed mock that mirrors its real marking scheme — reading is step one, recall is the exam.
Have a doubt on this topic?








