Quick Answer
Offer and Acceptance in Contract Law: Essential CLAT-Ready Rules Explained
A contract forms when an offer is made, accepted exactly and without conditions, and communicated back — on terms the offeror set. A counter-proposal kills the original offer. Silence is not acceptance, and acceptance posted completes the contract under the postal rule.
Visual Summary
- Offer first — invitation to treat is not an offer.
- Mirror rule — acceptance must match the offer exactly.
- Counter-offer kills — the original offer dies on variation.
- Postal rule — acceptance binds when posted, not received.
Offer vs Invitation to Treat
An offer (proposal) is a definite promise to be bound on specific terms — Section 2(a) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines it. An invitation to treat merely invites others to make offers: goods on a shop shelf, price catalogues, auction notices and tender advertisements are the classic examples. The customer walking in with money makes the offer; the shopkeeper accepts or rejects. Getting this distinction right decides who can reject whom.
An offer must be communicated to be effective — a person cannot accept an offer he does not know exists. It must also create a reasonable expectation that acceptance will conclude the deal; vague terms (“reasonable price”) leave nothing to accept.
Acceptance: The Mirror Rule
Section 2(b): when the person to whom the proposal is made signifies assent, the proposal becomes a promise. Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified (Section 7) — any variation is a counter-offer, which destroys the original offer and substitutes a new one. Accepting an offer while adding “subject to confirmation” is rejection in disguise.
Acceptance must also be in the mode the offeror prescribed, if he prescribed one; deviations at the offeror’s risk. And silence is never acceptance — an offeror cannot impose a duty to refuse.
Communication: The Postal Rule
Section 4 splits the clock. The communication of a proposal is complete when it comes to the knowledge of the offeree. The communication of acceptance is complete as against the proposer when the letter is posted — and as against the acceptor when it reaches the proposer. This is why a revocation posted after the acceptance letter was posted arrives too late: the contract already exists. For instantaneous communication (phone, telex), formation happens where and when the acceptance is received.
Exam Angle
CLAT legal-reasoning passages test exactly this doctrine through fact patterns — shop displays, counter-offers, revocation timing. Practise applying the rules in the CLAT mock and the Legal Reasoning sectional.
FAQ
Is a tender advertisement an offer?
No — it invites offers. Each bidder makes the offer; the authority accepts the one it selects.
Can acceptance be withdrawn after posting?
No. Acceptance is complete against the proposer on posting; revocation after that point is ineffective.
Related reading
- Breach of Contract and Legal Remedies: Damages Explained
- AILET 2027: Complete Guide and How It Differs From CLAT
Quick revision
- Offer first: — invitation to treat is not an offer.
- Mirror rule: — acceptance must match the offer exactly.
- Counter-offer kills: — the original offer dies on variation.
- Postal rule: — acceptance binds when posted, not received.
- Breach of Contract and Legal Remedies: Damages Explained
- AILET 2027: Complete Guide and How It Differs From CLAT
Have a doubt on this topic?







